The Artist - Blu-ray Review

'worthy of note both in and of itself and for its euphoric success against competition of much higher means and lower intentions'

Not being an expert on early silent cinema, I may struggle to contextualise The Artist as well as others have done. Be that as it may, in purely contemporary terms, the film's achievements should not be underestimated as time draws on past its Academy Award for Best Picture. That a silent, black and white film gained enough attention and support to win multiple Oscars, in a year where dreck like Transformers: Dark Of The Moon was also nominated and Michael Bay's retirement from that franchise was treated as headline fodder by many, is nothing short of remarkable.

Whilst it may not be the instant classic many proclaimed it - the reviews of the home release seem notably to have abandoned the hyperbole - Michel Hazanavicius' multi-Oscar winner is still a work of fine expression, rich in subtext and theme, warm of plot and character. Ludovic Bource's score - which secured the film one of its five Oscars - is nothing short of a masterpiece, booming triumphantly, without ever taking on the tweeness of more dated orchestral pieces.

The rich narrative too is mainly masterfully negotiated by Hazanavicius', who sets us up for his 'films-within-a-film-about-film' with the very first scene, George Valentin (Jean Dujardin) lurking behind the screen which his new feature plays on, to an audience packing out a literal and metaphorical auditorium. A sign hangs both unironically and ironically in the background; 'Please Be Silent'. The Artist is a film about the history of film but also about our changing consumption of it and (and The Artist might come to reflect this to a more potent degree as time goes on) the often fleeting level of success any given production can enjoy.

As the 'talkies' arrive, the sweeping modernity which threatens Valentin's way of life (look for this to also be dealt with in Terence Davies' forthcoming adaptation of Lewis Grassic Gibbon's Sunset Song) barrel rolls past those who dare to doubt it, Valentin clinging on in the romanticised hope that he can outlast progress. Is there a stab here from the film industry at the doubters of the current phase of 3D? Probably not from the director, but don't bet against the suggestion that some of the support for The Artist may well have been drummed up on the backing of this thematic thread.

For all its artistic brilliance (Guillaume Schiffman's cinematography is also exceptional) though, The Artist is not perfect. Scenes go on for far too long, a patience stretcher, particularly in the last half and Hazanavicius' grasp of narrative falters once or twice too often. The end is ill-explained, Valentin's relationship with his wife is muckily handled and ten minutes of cuts could have worked wonders. Still, this is fine, fine work, worthy of note both in and of itself and for its euphoric success against competition of much higher means and lower intentions.



8 comments:

  1. Those flaws that you mentioned, I don't see them as flaws... However, I'm glad that you still liked the film.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you saw past them Lesya and yes, I did still really enjoy the film. Also, incidentally; saw your post on finishing writing the other day and really pleased you changed your mind :)

      Delete
    2. Haha, I'm embarrassed for that post!

      Back to The Artist, I think it gets better upon revisits. For me at least it does.

      Delete
    3. Everyone has doubts, fear them not!

      That was my first watch but undoubtedly I'll go back to it, probably when it hits TV over here.

      Delete
  2. What was your feeling on the Blu Ray transfer? I've held off on picking this one up after seeing at the cinema as I can't decide if it's worth getting on Blu Ray or just DVD.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure I'd bother with the Blu-ray unless you can find it on a good deal. It looked fine, but not as impressive as some of the transfers I've seen. Wouldn't have it under 'must buy'.

      Delete
  3. I'm not going to say I'm well versed in Silent cinema (though I have seen, actually slept through, a fair few) and I can't say I agree with the positive sentiment: I'm a little more mixed. I found it enjoyable but also rather dull at the same time.

    Perhaps I didn't dwell in the thematics of the film as much as I did the main narrative but I never engaged in a (purposefully, it would seem) very formulaic story that lifts from A Star is Born/Singin' in the Rain.

    And let's be a little fair to Transformers, they're awful films from a narrative/acting perspective but on a technical one? Some of the best technical feats of the last few years, an interesting contrast with simplicity of The Artist. Or maybe not! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think there is an interesting contrast to be made there and the special effects category in general is just such an interesting treasure trove of mediocre films. Seem to remember The Golden Compass being nominated (winning?) one year and that was an abysmal murdering of a fantastic book.

      On The Artist, I would have liked more pace to it - which might have solved your problems - but I found enough to keep me going.

      Delete